Skip to content
Claim this template

Free course template · Global

Fair performance reviews

A ready-made course, live deck and two surveys for managers and anyone. 35 minutes, 6 lessons, 12-question final check. Last reviewed 28 October 2026; not legal advice.

Claim the templatePreview the courseDownload SCORM for your LMS

Free. No credit card. Edit everything.

Play a game from the course

Fair performance reviews: try 3 questions

Three questions from this course. Pick an answer, then see why.

Play the game

Game not loading? Open it in a new tab (opens in a new tab)

Three pieces that work together

Learners sign in, so every finish and score is recorded. 9 fields to fill in with your details.

Claim the template

6 lessons, about 35 minutes

Minutes are an estimate.

  • Lesson 1: Your role · 6 min

    Explain why fair reviews depend on clear criteria and evidence gathered all year.

  • Lesson 2: The rules: criteria and evidence · 6 min

    Rate against written, job-related criteria.

  • Lesson 3: Do / Don't: rating errors · 8 min

    Recognise and correct four common rating errors: recency, halo/horns, central tendency, similarity.

  • Lesson 4: The conversation and the write-up · 5 min

    Write review comments that are specific, behaviour-based and free of style or personality labels.

  • Lesson 5: Calibrate and document · 5 min

    Prepare for calibration and the review conversation, and document the outcome.

  • Lesson 6: Final assessment · 5 min

    12 questions, 80% to pass. The result is saved to the learner's record.

Claim the template

Inside this course

Taken from the course itself.

Sample questions, with answers

  1. What most likely explains the different ratings?

    • The rating followed visibility rather than the written criteria and evidence
    • One analyst worked harder
    • The criteria were too detailed
    • Time zones should affect ratings

    Answer: The rating followed visibility rather than the written criteria and evidence. With the same results, the difference came from who was seen. Written criteria and an evidence log keep the focus on the work.

    Lesson 1: Your role

  2. Which log entry is the most useful?

    • "14 March: closed the Henderson ticket in 2 days, client replied with thanks."
    • "Good attitude."
    • "Not sure about her long-term potential."
    • "Seems quieter lately."

    Answer: "14 March: closed the Henderson ticket in 2 days, client replied with thanks.". It has a date, a result and an outcome. The others are impressions that cannot be checked.

    Lesson 2: The rules: criteria and evidence

  3. A manager gives everyone "meets" so that no one is upset. Which error is this?

    • Central tendency
    • Recency
    • Halo
    • Similarity

    Answer: Central tendency. Central tendency means clustering ratings in the middle. The fix is to compare each person with the written standard.

    Lesson 3: Do / Don't: rating errors

A scenario from "The conversation and the write-up"

Review conversation with Darius Johnson, rated "meets", who expected "exceeds". Best = walk through the criteria and the evidence for each, listen to evidence he brings, agree what "exceeds" would look like next cycle, and say how he can raise a disagreement your review appeal process; weaker = "Calibration decided, not me"; wrong = change the rating on the spot to avoid conflict without new evidence.

Related articles

An article from the AhaSlides blog that uses this course.

Common questions

Yes. Claiming the template and editing it are free.

Yes. The course is self-paced and online, and the live deck lets you add a live session in the room or online.

Before each review cycle (short refresher) + full course every 2 years (best practice).

Managers and anyone who rates or reviews others' performance (including calibration panels).

Record completion in your own LMS or record system, so you can show who finished the course and when.

Your own details, each highlighted inside the course:
  • Rating scale and criteria
  • Review cycle dates
  • Performance system
  • Calibration process
  • Review appeal process
  • HR contact
  • LMS or record system
Then edit anything else you like: wording, scenarios, your logo.
Visit the help centre (opens in a new tab)