Speaking up patient safety training: how to train junior residents to challenge attending physicians

No items found.
Blog thumbnail image

Junior residents speak up more reliably when they have rehearsed a specific phrase, know the approved route for escalating and have seen attendings respond well to being challenged. This guide is for directors of medical education and residency programme leads. It covers five decisions: what the resident must be able to do, how to diagnose why they do not do it now, how to design practice and feedback, how to work through a realistic case, and how to assess the skill and plan transfer to the ward. It is about training design and behaviour, not clinical advice. Use your own institution's approved escalation process, and ask a clinician from your programme to review the case and rubric before use.

What the research says, and does not say

A 2014 literature review by Okuyama and colleagues, "Speaking up for patient safety by hospital-based health care professionals", found that fear of other people's responses and conflict, and the attitude of leaders and superiors, affect whether staff speak up. The US Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality publishes TeamSTEPPS, a teamwork training programme that teaches structured phrases, including "CUS" (I am Concerned, I am Uncomfortable, this is a Safety issue) and a two-challenge rule, so that a junior person has words ready.

The review covers mixed study types, and TeamSTEPPS is a published method, not proof that any one version works in your programme. Use both as a starting point, then check the results with your own residents and attendings.

Quick facts

QuestionShort answer
What must the resident do?Raise a concern using an approved escalation process.
Why might they not?Hierarchy, fear of consequences, unclear route or an attending who seems unreceptive.
What should practice include?A specific phrase, the escalation steps and feedback on how the other person heard it.
Who else needs practice?Attendings, who must rehearse receiving a challenge.
What should assessment show?A clear concern and an appropriate escalation in a new case.
What can training not fix?A culture or policy that punishes speaking up.

1. Describe the performance problem

State the observable task: a resident notices a discrepancy in a senior colleague's proposed action and raises a concern using the approved escalation process. Describe it in terms someone could watch: what was said, to whom, in what order and what happened next. Avoid vague goals such as "be more assertive". Our guide to matching learning activities to Bloom's taxonomy helps you separate what residents must apply (use the phrase and the route) from what they must evaluate (decide whether a concern is serious enough to escalate).

2. Diagnose the learning and context gaps

Compare the task with what residents practise and are assessed on today. If they are only assessed on clinical knowledge, nobody has tested speaking up. Then check the context before prescribing training:

  • Route. Do residents know the approved escalation process, and does it work at night, on call or with a single attending present?
  • Tools and procedures. Is there a way to escalate that does not require confronting the person directly?
  • Response. How do attendings react when challenged? Residents notice this faster than any policy.
  • Incentives. Does anything in evaluations or reputation make speaking up costly?

Training will not help if the process is unclear or the response to a concern is punitive. Fix those first, or alongside.

3. Design preparation and practice

Check prerequisites with a short diagnostic: do residents know the escalation route and the language they are expected to use? Self-paced study suits this. Then move to practice that mirrors the task:

  1. Rehearse the words. Short, structured phrases, such as the CUS words, give a junior person something to say when they are anxious.
  2. Practise with realistic cases. Present a short scenario with a discrepancy and ask the resident to say what they would do and say.
  3. Give feedback linked to decisions. Comment on the specific words and the escalation step, not on personality.
  4. Use psychologically safe M&M conferences. Morbidity and mortality conferences, where teams review cases, can model how to discuss a concern without blame.
  5. Rehearse receiving a challenge. Attendings need practice responding without defensiveness. A supervisor who gets this wrong undoes the training.

Live instructor input adds most value in the feedback on tone and wording. Asynchronous review is enough for checking the route and the policy.

4. A worked case with feedback and a retry

Illustrative. The residency programme lead and a clinician should validate the case and the answer criteria before use.

The case. A junior clinician notices a discrepancy in a senior colleague's proposed action, in a simulated scenario designed by your programme.

The task. Explain what you would do, cite the evidence you noticed and say what further information or support you would need.

A first attempt. "I would say nothing, because the attending has more experience and probably knows something I do not." A reviewer asks what the discrepancy was, what the approved route allows when a resident is unsure, and what would happen if the concern were right and nobody said it. The resident has no answer to any of them.

Feedback and retry. The reviewer notes that the resident gave a reason for silence but did not use any part of the escalation process. The resident is asked for a new plan.

A stronger attempt. The resident names the discrepancy in factual terms, says the phrase their programme teaches for raising a concern, asks the attending to confirm the plan, and says they will use the approved escalation route if the concern is not resolved. They say what they still need: the attending's reasoning and who to contact if the attending is unavailable.

Why each response is defensible or incomplete. Judge against approved criteria, not the reviewer's preference. The first attempt does not raise a concern, so it counts as a critical error. The second names the concern, uses the approved route and stays open to being wrong.

5. Assess capability and plan transfer

Assess clarity of the concern and appropriateness of the escalation in a new case, not the one practised. Add a workplace follow-up: a supervisor's observation, a review of a real escalation or a debrief after a simulated scenario, as your programme's policies allow.

Criterion0: absent or unsupported1: partial, with omissions2: complete and justified
Task executionRaises no concern.Raises a concern without using the approved route.Raises a clear concern and uses the approved route.
ReasoningGives no reason.Gives a reason without evidence.Cites what was observed, names alternatives and states uncertainty.
BoundariesActs outside approved procedures.Notes limits without a plan.Uses approved procedures and seeks help when information or authority is missing.

This rubric is a proposed starting point, not a validated standard. Define critical errors separately, for example staying silent when the approved route clearly required escalation. An overall score must never hide a critical failure.

To check the programme, compare baseline and unseen follow-up tasks. Measure the clarity of the concern and the appropriateness of the escalation. Define the population, denominator and timing before you start, and look for concurrent changes, such as a new reporting system or a change of attendings, before you credit the training.

Where interactive delivery helps

Interactive formats help where residents should commit before they hear what others chose. In a live session, you can ask every resident to type what they would say, show the spread of answers anonymously and discuss the differences. Self-paced delivery suits the route and policy check beforehand. AhaSlides, an all-in-one engagement platform for teams and classrooms, supports interactive learning and both live and self-paced delivery. Check how you would run the session in your own workflow before you rely on it. For a wider view of practice with scenarios, see our guide to scenario-based healthcare compliance training.

What speaking-up training will not fix

  • A punitive culture. If speaking up is penalised, residents learn to stay quiet.
  • An unclear or unusable route. A phrase without a process does not lead anywhere.
  • Attendings who are not trained to receive a challenge. Practice for residents alone is incomplete.
  • Evidence limits. The review above covers mixed study types. Measure your own programme.

Frequently asked questions

What is speaking up in patient safety?

Raising a concern about a possible risk to a patient, to the person responsible or through an approved escalation route, even when that person is more senior.

What is the CUS tool?

A phrase set from TeamSTEPPS: I am Concerned, I am Uncomfortable, this is a Safety issue.

Should attendings be trained too?

Yes. Attendings need to practise receiving a challenge and responding without defensiveness.

How do you assess whether residents will speak up?

Use a new case, score the clarity of the concern and the appropriateness of the escalation, and add a workplace follow-up where your policies allow.

Who should review the case and rubric?

A clinician from your programme and the residency programme lead, before anyone is scored.

Where to start

Pick one situation your residents are likely to meet. Write the approved route and the words you expect, run a short case with both residents and attendings, and score it against the rubric. Compare the result with what your residents say they would do.

To see how a session like this could run live or self-paced, explore AhaSlides.

Subscribe for tips, insights and strategies to boost audience engagement.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Check out other posts

AhaSlides is used by Forbes America's top 500 companies. Experience the power of engagement today.

Get started free
© 2026 AhaSlides Pte Ltd